Vermont Seeks Injunction Against Clearview AI

  • Gizmodo
  • Vermont Seeks Injunction Against Clearview AI

Photo: Getty

Vermont Attorney General T.J. Donovan filed a lawsuit on Wednesday against the controversial face recognition company Clearview AI alleging its efforts to collect images of Vermonters without their consent to fuel a law enforcement database is in violation of multiple state laws.

“I am disturbed by this practice, particularly the practice of collecting and selling children’s facial recognition data,” Donovan said in a statement. “This practice is unscrupulous, unethical, and contrary to public policy. I will continue to fight for the privacy of Vermonters, particularly our most vulnerable.”

Clearview AI has faced intense scrutiny in past weeks from lawmakers and privacy advocates due to its practice of “scraping” images of Americans from dozens of websites, including Facebook and YouTube, without their permission and in apparent violation of those websites’ terms of service. The images feed a database that reportedly aids police in identifying individuals based only on a photograph. Use of the technology is wholly unregulated.

Vermont Seeks Injunction Against Clearview AI

Amid the ongoing backlash, the New York Times reported last week that Clearview AI had allowed numerous, exorbitantly wealthy individuals to toy around with the database for fun, despite claiming publicly that its technology is “available only for law enforcement agencies and select security professionals to use as an investigative tool.”

The complaint filed by Donovan in the Chittenden Superior Court alleges that Clearview AI has committed multiple violations of the Vermont Consumer Protection Act and the state’s year-old data broker law, which requires businesses collecting and selling data about Vermonters to register with state authorities.

“No Vermont state or local law enforcement agencies have used the app. Clearview AI collects the facial recognition data of Vermont children, as well as adults, without their notice or consent,” Donovan’s office said.

The state has also filed a motion asking a judge to order Clearview AI to immediately halt the collection of information about Vermont residents. The legal efforts follow a cease-and-desist letter sent by the assistant attorney general, Ryan Kriger, on March 5.

Vermont Consumer Protection Act authorizes the state attorney general to conduct investigations and seek monetary relief—up to $10,000 per violation—on behalf of consumers. The cease-and-desist letter informed Clearview: “Each photograph downloaded or Vermonter impacted is a separate and distinct violation.”

Vermont Seeks Injunction Against Clearview AI

Clearview AI’s CEO, Hoan Ton-That, has publicly asserted a First Amendment defense in response to criticism of his company’s data collection methods, arguing the company has every right to “public information.” The companies from which Clearview is collecting data do not agree. Several, including Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube, have sent the company cease-and-desist letters and have threatened additional legal action.

Below is the full statement provided to Gizmodo by Clearview AI attorney Tor Ekeland:

Clearview AI is one of the most innovative, effective and accurate law-enforcement tools on the market. Not only does it protect victims by helping law enforcement apprehend child rapists, murderers, and thieves, its accuracy protects the innocent from being falsely accused — all by simply using public images available to everyone on the public Internet. If an image is marked private, it remains private. Clearview AI will not index it.

Clearview AI operates in a manner similar to search engines like Google and Bing. Clearview AI, however, collects far less data than Google and Bing, because Clearview AI only collects public images and their web address. That’s all. Google, Bing and Facebook collect far more data, including names, addresses, financial and health information and shopping habits.

Clearview AI operates in strict accordance with the U.S. Constitution and American law. We would welcome the opportunity to work collaboratively with the State of Vermont — outside the adversarial environment of a courtroom — to further refine our proven, crime-solving technology for the benefit of all. However, we are ready to defend our, and the public’s, Constitutional right to access freely available public information.

Did you like this article? Why not check it out more from Gizmodo!

FRESHEST

Here's the latest news
Cloud Technologies

Benefits of Cloud Technologies in Education

Description: This is the new era for students. The era of technology. See how cloud technologies made studying and storing files for students unbelievably easy.  Any cloud-based technologies have a tremendous number of benefits that help students all over the...

Network connection and cloud storage technology concept

YouTube is, by far, one of the best platforms to use for marketing purposes due to the massive amount of traffic the site receives on a daily basis. However, getting exposure on YouTube is not always the easiest thing to...

top view of woman using laptop and drinking coffee at modern workplace with youtube website

In the modern world of networking, there's a lot of useful ways to connect your network devices. A DAC Cable offers a flexible means of transmitting a large amount of data between devices effectively, such as connecting 10G switches in...

Woman networking engineer near working server rack
Laptop Bad Credit

How to finance a laptop with bad credit

Bad credit, one of the biggest hurdles in life when it comes to just about anything that you want to purchase that requires payments. Sometimes life takes a turn for the worst and it ends up affecting literally every aspect...

Working on a laptop

One of the things we're often asked about is technologies that have been around, seemingly forever but are still popular even in modern days. There are a lot of examples of technologies that, even though they were invented quite some...

VPN, Personal Online Security, Virtual Private Network
Load More
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap